Small Town Dicks Podcast : The Dark Side of Small Town America


In the expansive landscape of true crime podcasts, where narratives often center around the gritty allure of big city crime, Small Town Dicks emerges as a beacon, illuminating the shadows cast by crimes in the heartlands of America. With its unique premise and compelling storytelling, this podcast, now in its twelfth season, delves into the captivating world of small-town crime through the eyes of the detectives who lived it. Let’s embark on a journey through the heartland of criminal investigation and emotional tumult as we explore the riveting tales showcased in Small Town Dicks.

Small Town Dicks Podcast Review

Podcast Review : Small Town Dick

“Small Town Dicks” emerges as one of the best true crime podcast as it explores the gritty realities that lurk beneath the veneer of small-town America. Delving into the intricate narratives of real detectives, this podcast offers a unique perspective on crime-solving, emotion, and bias. With seasoned hosts including veteran detectives Dan and Dave, forensic expert Paul Holes, and actress Yeardley Smith, “Small Town Dicks” takes listeners on a gripping journey through the complexities of investigative work.

Through riveting anecdotes and introspective dialogues, “Small Town Dicks” dismantles the myth of the stoic detective, revealing the emotional undercurrents that drive each investigation. From gut instincts leading to legal triumphs to navigating moral quagmires, this podcast confronts the challenges and triumphs of the justice system with nuance and empathy. As a beacon of insight and reflection, “Small Town Dicks” not only entertains but also prompts listeners to reconsider their perceptions of law enforcement and the pursuit of justice.



Small Town Dicks, a riveting podcast, offers a compelling dive into the underbelly of small-town crime across America. Hosted by actress Yeardley Smith alongside veteran detectives Dan and Dave, and forensic expert Paul Holes, the podcast delves into real-life cases solved by the very detectives who experienced them. Through gripping storytelling and candid interviews, Small Town Dicks exposes the emotional nuances, biases, and challenges inherent in investigative work, challenging the conventional portrayal of detectives as stoic figures. With each episode, listeners are drawn into a world where gut instincts, emotional connections, and institutional biases shape the pursuit of justice, providing a captivating and thought-provoking glimpse into the intricacies of law enforcement in America’s heartland.

The Cast: Icons of the Investigation

At the helm of Small Town Dicks are the veteran twin detectives Dan and Dave, whose decades of experience infuse every episode with authenticity and insight. Alongside them stands the esteemed forensic expert Paul Holes, renowned for his contributions to cold case investigations and revered as a New York Times bestselling author. Guiding listeners through each story is the talented actress Yeardley Smith, whose hosting prowess adds a layer of empathy and intrigue to the narratives.


A Narrative of Emotion and Bias

Unlike the impersonal portrayals often seen in mainstream media, Small Town Dicks unflinchingly exposes the emotional undercurrents that drive investigative work. Through poignant anecdotes and introspective dialogues, the podcast dismantles the myth of the stoic detective, revealing the intricate web of feelings, biases, and background influences that shape each investigation.

The Power of Emotional Connection

In the episode “Girl for Rent,” we witness the pivotal role played by emotional intuition in cracking a harrowing case of child abuse. Sergeant David’s unwavering instinct and determination to follow his gut lead to the rescue of a young victim and the prosecution of her abuser. Here, the podcast illustrates how emotional involvement can be the catalyst for justice, bridging the chasm between instinct and evidence.


The Sociopath and the Whistleblower

In the chilling miniseries “The Sociopath and the Whistleblower,” Small Town Dicks delves into the murky waters of moral ambiguity and institutional prejudice. Lieutenant Scott’s journey from skepticism to advocacy underscores the profound impact of emotional transformation within the realm of law enforcement. Through Scott’s narrative arc, the podcast elucidates the complex interplay between personal bias, institutional loyalty, and the pursuit of truth.

Redefining Justice

As listeners, we are confronted with the stark reality that the pursuit of justice is often fraught with human fallibility and systemic shortcomings. Yet, within this acknowledgment lies a glimmer of hope—a testament to the transformative power of empathy and self-reflection. Small Town Dicks serves not only as a platform for storytelling but also as a catalyst for societal introspection and change.



In the tapestry of true crime narratives, Small Town Dicks stands as a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the enduring quest for truth. Through its candid portrayal of small-town crimes and the detectives who unravel them, the podcast invites us to confront our own biases, question institutional norms, and strive for a more equitable legal system. In a world where justice is often elusive, Small Town Dicks reminds us that the pursuit of truth begins with acknowledging the complexities of the human experience. In the heartland of America, where the shadows of small towns conceal both secrets and sorrows, Small Town Dicks shines a light, illuminating the path towards justice, empathy, and understanding.

If you are interested in listening to a variety of podcasts, you may want to check out the best podcasts in various genres such as crickettrue crimehorrorsci-fimotivational, spiritualfoodparentingentrepreneurshipfor kidsWorld War II, home automation, learning new languagesstarting a podcasthistoryfinancecryptocurrencyfootballmental health, and wildlife



1. What is Small Town Dicks podcast about?

Small Town Dicks is a podcast that delves into the world of small-town crime in the USA. Each episode features real detectives sharing their experiences in solving major cases in their respective small towns. Hosted by actress Yeardley Smith and veteran twin detectives Dan and Dave, along with forensic expert Paul Holes, the podcast offers insights into the emotional and investigative aspects of these crimes.


2. Who are the hosts of Small Town Dicks podcast?

The podcast is hosted by actress Yeardley Smith, known for her role as the voice of Lisa Simpson, along with veteran twin detectives Dan and Dave, and forensic expert Paul Holes. Together, they provide a unique perspective on the cases discussed in the podcast.


3. What makes Small Town Dicks podcast stand out from other true crime podcasts?

Small Town Dicks stands out for its focus on small-town crime, offering a perspective often overlooked in mainstream media. The podcast also delves into the emotional aspects of detective work, showcasing the impact of intuition, bias, and compassion on solving cases.

4. Can I listen to previous seasons of Small Town Dicks podcast?

Yes, all seasons of Small Town Dicks are available for streaming, allowing listeners to explore past episodes and cases at their convenience.

5. Are there any companion shows related to Small Town Dicks podcast?

Yes, Small Town Dicks has a companion show called The Briefing Room, which provides further insights into the complex relationship between law enforcement and the communities they serve. This additional podcast offers a deeper dive into the themes explored in Small Town Dicks.

6. Where can I find more information about the detectives featured on Small Town Dicks?

While the detectives featured on Small Town Dicks use pseudonyms to protect their identities, listeners can find updates and additional information about the podcast on its official website and social media channels.

7. How can I stay updated on new episodes and recommendations from Small Town Dicks podcast?

To receive the latest podcast reviews and episode recommendations via email, listeners can sign up for the Small Town Dicks weekly newsletter on the podcast’s official website.

8. Is Small Town Dicks podcast suitable for all audiences?

While Small Town Dicks explores real-life crime stories, some episodes may contain sensitive or graphic content. Listener discretion is advised, particularly for younger or more sensitive audiences.

9. How can I support Small Town Dicks podcast?

Supporting Small Town Dicks can be done by subscribing to the podcast on your preferred streaming platform, leaving positive reviews, and sharing episodes with friends and family. Additionally, consider following the podcast on social media and engaging with its content to show your support for the creators and their work.

10. Where can I listen to Small Town Dicks podcast?

Small Town Dicks podcast is available for streaming on various platforms, including Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts, and the podcast’s official website. Simply search for “Small Town Dicks” on your preferred platform to start listening to episodes.

About Author

The Podcasting Research Team is a dynamic and passionate group of young researchers who are dedicated to exploring the world of podcasting. Whether you’re a podcast creator, a marketer, or simply a curious listener, the work of The Podcasting Research Team can provide valuable insights into the trends and best practices in the podcasting world.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *