Why True Crime Podcasts Have Captivated the World
In recent years, true crime podcasts have taken the world by storm, attracting millions of listeners with their compelling storytelling, gripping narratives, and often bone-chilling stories. For many, these podcasts are not just entertainment; they offer insights into the human psyche, criminal behavior, and the justice system. Whether you’re a fan of mysteries, courtroom drama, or in-depth investigations, true crime podcasts have something for everyone.
If you’re new to this genre or looking to expand your podcast library, here’s a curated list of the 10 Top True Crime Podcasts that are must-listens in 2024. Each of these podcasts has made a significant impact on the genre and promises hours of captivating listening.
1. Serial
- Host: Sarah Koenig
- Launch Year: 2014
- Average Episode Length: 30-60 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “The Alibi” (Season 1, Episode 1)
Serial is often considered the podcast that put true crime on the map. Hosted by Sarah Koenig, the show dives into a different case each season, with the most famous being its inaugural season covering the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee. This meticulously researched podcast redefined storytelling in audio form, weaving interviews, court documents, and expert analysis into a narrative that keeps listeners hooked.
Why You Should Listen: Serial’s in-depth investigative approach and riveting storytelling have inspired countless other podcasts. It’s a must-listen for anyone new to the genre.
2. Criminal
- Host: Phoebe Judge
- Launch Year: 2014
- Average Episode Length: 20-30 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “Animal Instincts”
Criminal explores a wide array of criminal activities and delves into the minds of those involved. Phoebe Judge’s soothing voice contrasts with the dark subject matter, adding a unique charm to the show. Unlike traditional true crime podcasts that focus solely on murder, Criminal covers an eclectic range of cases, from historical crimes to bizarre heists.
Why You Should Listen: If you enjoy short, fascinating stories that explore the complexities of crime beyond murder mysteries, Criminal is the perfect fit.
3. My Favorite Murder
- Hosts: Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
- Launch Year: 2016
- Average Episode Length: 60-90 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “Stay Out of the Forest”
My Favorite Murder combines humor with true crime, creating a space where fans of the genre can laugh while still engaging in thoughtful discussions about crime. Hosts Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark bring their comedy background to the table, lightening up grim subjects with witty banter.
Why You Should Listen: The podcast’s informal and relatable style makes it accessible for those who might be new to the genre or prefer a lighter take on dark stories.
4. Casefile
- Host: Anonymous
- Launch Year: 2016
- Average Episode Length: 60-120 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “Case 1: The Wanda Beach Murders”
Casefile is known for its straightforward and factual storytelling style. The host, who remains anonymous, dives deep into cases, often focusing on lesser-known or unsolved crimes. The show’s thorough research and dedication to accuracy make it stand out.
Why You Should Listen: If you appreciate fact-driven, narrative-style podcasts without unnecessary frills, Casefile should be at the top of your list.
5. Sword and Scale
- Host: Mike Boudet
- Launch Year: 2014
- Average Episode Length: 60 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “Episode 20” (The Cannibal Cop Case)
Sword and Scale doesn’t shy away from exploring the darkest sides of human nature. The podcast covers disturbing cases with a no-holds-barred approach. Mike Boudet uses audio clips, 911 calls, and police interviews to immerse listeners in each story.
Why You Should Listen: This is the perfect podcast for those who prefer intense, detailed narratives and aren’t easily disturbed.
6. Someone Knows Something
- Host: David Ridgen
- Launch Year: 2016
- Average Episode Length: 30-60 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “Season 1: Adrien McNaughton” (Episode 1)
Someone Knows Something is a Canadian podcast that blends documentary-style reporting with immersive storytelling. Each season focuses on a different cold case, with host David Ridgen revisiting the cases and interviewing those involved.
Why You Should Listen: The show’s compelling, empathetic approach and focus on cold cases make it a unique and emotional listening experience.
7. The Last Podcast on the Left
- Hosts: Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, Henry Zebrowski
- Launch Year: 2011
- Average Episode Length: 60-120 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “The Jonestown Series”
The Last Podcast on the Left merges horror, comedy, and true crime into a single, engaging podcast. The hosts’ blend of humor and in-depth research sets this podcast apart from others in the genre.
Why You Should Listen: The irreverent, humorous take on dark topics is a great way to balance true crime fascination with a lighter touch.
8. The Murder Squad
- Hosts: Billy Jensen and Paul Holes
- Launch Year: 2019
- Average Episode Length: 60-90 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “The Golden State Killer”
The Murder Squad is hosted by investigative journalist Billy Jensen and retired detective Paul Holes. They actively involve listeners in solving cold cases by providing tips and clues that listeners can follow up on.
Why You Should Listen: If you want a podcast that actively engages you in solving cases, The Murder Squad is the perfect choice.
9. Morbid: A True Crime Podcast
- Hosts: Ashleigh Kelley and Alaina Urquhart
- Launch Year: 2018
- Average Episode Length: 60-120 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “The Ted Bundy Series”
Morbid is a true crime and horror podcast hosted by Alaina Urquhart, an autopsy technician, and Ashleigh Kelley, her niece. The duo blends chilling tales with a dash of humor, resulting in a balanced yet thrilling experience.
Why You Should Listen: If you love well-researched stories with a bit of humor, Morbid should be on your playlist.
10. Up and Vanished
- Host: Payne Lindsey
- Launch Year: 2016
- Average Episode Length: 60-90 minutes
- Best Episode to Start With: “Episode 1: Cold as Alaska”
Up and Vanished gained popularity by re-investigating cold cases, starting with the disappearance of Tara Grinstead. Host Payne Lindsey’s documentary-style narration, interviews, and deep dives into cases make the podcast captivating from start to finish.
Why You Should Listen: If you’re fascinated by unsolved disappearances and investigative journalism, this is the podcast for you.
Comparison Table of Top 7 True Crime Podcasts
| Podcast Name | Host(s) | Average Episode Length | Type of Crime Focused | Unique Selling Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Serial | Sarah Koenig | 30-60 minutes | Cold cases | Pioneering true crime podcast |
| Criminal | Phoebe Judge | 20-30 minutes | Varied crimes | Short, engaging stories |
| My Favorite Murder | Karen Kilgariff, Georgia Hardstark | 60-90 minutes | Murder cases | Humor and true crime blend |
| Casefile | Anonymous | 60-120 minutes | Unsolved cases, murders | Factual, straight-to-the-point narration |
| Sword and Scale | Mike Boudet | 60 minutes | Violent crimes | Unfiltered and intense storytelling |
| Someone Knows Something | David Ridgen | 30-60 minutes | Cold cases | Documentary-style investigation |
| The Last Podcast on the Left | Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, Henry Zebrowski | 60-120 minutes | Varied crimes, horror | Dark humor meets in-depth research |