HS2 Future Still in Flux: Podcast Exposes ‘Mess’ as Costs Top £100B & Northern Routes Left Hanging
The future of the HS2 rail line beyond Birmingham hangs in the balance, as a new BBC Radio 4 podcast titled Derailed: The Story of HS2 reveals. The government continues to deliberate over the fate of the proposed routes to Manchester and Leeds, with the Department for Transport stating that these extensions remain “under consultation.”
The ten-part podcast series, hosted by award-winning journalist Kate Lamble, unearths years of controversy, political mismanagement, and shifting goals behind what was once hailed as Britain’s flagship transport infrastructure project.
HS2: The Project That Promised to Transform Britain
HS2 (High Speed 2) was first proposed in 2009 as a high-speed rail project designed to link London, Birmingham, Manchester, and Leeds. The goal was ambitious: slash journey times, increase capacity on the existing rail network, and rebalance the British economy by better connecting the North and South.
Key original goals:
London to Birmingham in under 50 minutes
Improved regional connectivity
Stimulated economic growth in the North and Midlands
But fast forward to 2025, and the northern legs of HS2 have been paused indefinitely. Costs have ballooned, public trust has eroded, and the original vision remains unfulfilled.
🎧 Derailed: The Podcast That Tells All
The BBC Radio 4 podcast, released on 14 July 2025, dives into the full story of HS2. Through in-depth interviews and investigative reporting, host Kate Lamble pieces together the high hopes, mounting frustrations, and eventual unraveling of the rail project.
Episode Highlights:
Lord Peter Hendy, Minister of State for Rail, candidly admits: “There’s no doubt about it… what we have resolved to do is to sort it out.”
Hendy confirms the government is still deciding what to do with land acquired for the now-paused extensions to Manchester and Leeds.
The current Birmingham to London leg is projected to cost at least £100 billion due to inflation, though Hendy disputes these figures, stating, “I haven’t seen numbers like that, except in the media.”
The podcast also features:
Former Prime Minister Boris Johnson
Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham
Former HS2 chairs Sir Douglas Oakervee, Brian Briscoe, Allan Cook
HS2 insiders including Andrew Bruce and Doug Thornton
💰 A £100 Billion Stretch: The Financial Reality
Originally budgeted at £37.5 billion, HS2’s projected cost has more than doubled. The line from London to Birmingham alone is now estimated at £81 billion, with final costs likely exceeding £100 billion when adjusted for inflation.
Cost Breakdown:
Phase 1 (London to Birmingham): £81 billion
Projected inflation and overruns: £19–25 billion
Phases to Manchester/Leeds: status under consultation
These staggering figures have led to growing scrutiny over fiscal responsibility, planning oversight, and value for taxpayer money.
HS2 Ltd responded in the podcast: “This cycle of cost increases and delays must be broken. We have a comprehensive plan to reset the programme.”
🔍 Under Consultation: What Does It Really Mean?
“Under consultation” has become political shorthand for uncertainty. With work halted on the northern phases, the government must decide what to do with the land, planning permissions, and partial infrastructure already in place.
Key Possibilities:
Resume the full project if finances stabilize
Repurpose acquired land for regional rail or housing
Devolve decisions to local authorities or private sector
The lack of a clear direction has sparked criticism from local leaders and transport advocates.
🗣️ Voices of Support and Concern
Former PM Boris Johnson defends the original vision: “Great infrastructure projects depend on political will. HS2 was clearly going to be part of rebalancing Britain.”
However, Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham criticizes the delays and ambiguity: “The North has been promised transformation for years. HS2 was a commitment, not a suggestion.”
Insiders like Andrew Bruce and Doug Thornton express frustration over internal mismanagement and shifting political agendas.
🌍 Regional Impact: The Lost Promise of Northern Growth
HS2 was meant to be the cornerstone of the “Northern Powerhouse”—an initiative to boost economic performance in the North of England.
Projected Benefits Now in Limbo:
Job creation across Leeds and Manchester
Infrastructure investment spillover
Fast-tracked business and logistics networks
With the cancellation of key northern legs, the ripple effects on regional economies, housing, and transport integration are being widely felt.
🛠️ HS2 Ltd’s “Reset” Plan
In response to criticisms, HS2 Ltd has introduced a comprehensive reform plan aiming to restore credibility, minimize further delays, and tighten cost controls.
Main features of the reset:
Independent oversight of future phases
New performance-based contractor evaluations
Greater transparency in reporting progress
Stronger community engagement in affected areas
🎙️ The Role of Media: How Derailed Changed the Narrative
BBC’s Derailed podcast is more than a documentary—it’s a tool of public accountability. It frames HS2 not merely as a failed project, but as a cautionary tale of governance, ambition, and consequence.
Podcast impact:
Reignited national debate
Forced public statements from ministers
Increased demand for transparency and answers
🧭 Where Do We Go From Here?
Britain’s future rail strategy remains uncertain. While the Birmingham to London leg will continue, the full promise of HS2 is yet unfulfilled.
Key questions ahead:
Will the government revive the Manchester/Leeds extension?
Can HS2 regain public trust and political support?
What alternatives exist for boosting northern infrastructure?
📝 Conclusion: A Cautionary Tale in Concrete and Steel
Derailed: The Story of HS2 peels back the layers of one of Britain’s most controversial projects, exposing systemic issues in planning, financing, and political decision-making.
As public scrutiny intensifies and the nation watches closely, the final chapters of HS2 are yet to be written—but thanks to the BBC’s investigative work, they will not go unnoticed.
