What Your Therapist Thinks Podcast Returns With Season 2 & New Substack
The fast-rising mental health podcast What Your Therapist Thinks is officially making a comeback with season two, alongside the launch of a brand-new companion Substack newsletter aimed at expanding its listener community.
Hosts Kristie Plantinga and Felicia Keller Boyle confirmed the show’s return after what they described as a breakout debut season, with the podcast quickly becoming one of the most talked-about therapy-focused audio series in recent months.
Season two is scheduled to premiere on 25 February 2026, while the official trailer is already live.
Season Two Confirmed After a Chart-Topping First Run
Following the success of its first season, What Your Therapist Thinks is returning with fresh episodes that will continue its signature approach—mixing professional therapy insights with real-world conversations about modern mental health culture.
The show has gained attention for challenging the way mental health topics are often simplified online, particularly across social media platforms where psychological terms are frequently used without full understanding.
According to the hosts, season two will build on the momentum of season one, featuring new expert contributors, broader topics, and deeper discussions designed to help listeners feel informed and emotionally validated.
Who Hosts What Your Therapist Thinks?
The podcast is led by two professionals who bring a blend of therapy knowledge and digital-era perspective.
Kristie Plantinga
Kristie Plantinga is the founder of BestTherapists.com, a platform created to help individuals find and connect with licensed therapists and mental health support services.
Her role on the podcast often focuses on breaking down common misconceptions in therapy culture and explaining why mental health conversations need more nuance than social media trends typically allow.
Felicia Keller Boyle
Felicia Keller Boyle is a licensed somatic therapist, meaning she specializes in the connection between emotional trauma, mental health and the body’s nervous system responses.
Her perspective brings clinical depth to the podcast, especially when discussing topics like trauma recovery, anxiety, emotional regulation, and self-image.
Together, the two hosts have developed a reputation for delivering mental health discussions in a way that feels honest, relatable, and grounded in real therapy practices.
What Made Season One a Breakout Success?
The podcast’s debut season became a standout success, particularly on Apple Podcasts, where it climbed rapidly through the rankings.
Highlights from Season One Performance:
Reached #1 in the Mental Health category on Apple Podcasts
Also hit #1 in Health and Fitness
Gained a strong following through shareable clips and relatable discussions
Earned praise for offering therapist-led perspectives rather than internet speculation
The popularity of season one reflects a growing demand for trustworthy mental health content, as more people seek clarity on topics like trauma, boundaries, anxiety, ADHD, and relationship dynamics.
Challenging Viral Therapy Language and Online Mental Health Myths
One of the biggest reasons the podcast has stood out is its commitment to unpacking the way therapy terms have become mainstream — and often misused.
Kristie Plantinga addressed this directly, saying:
“The internet loves throwing around words like ‘gaslighting’ and ‘toxic,’ but most of the time, the context is missing.”
Her statement highlights the podcast’s core message: therapy language can be empowering, but without professional context, it can also be misleading and damaging.
Felicia Keller Boyle Promises the Same Energy for Season Two
Felicia Keller Boyle said the response to season one exceeded expectations and reassured listeners that season two will continue delivering honest, humorous and relatable conversations.
She added:
“We were mind-blown by the love for season one. This season, we’re keeping that same energy: real chats with expert therapists that will make you feel seen, and occasionally, make you laugh out loud.”
The podcast’s tone has become one of its biggest strengths — balancing serious topics with warmth, realism and humor.
Season Two Will Continue Weekly Episodes With New Guest Experts
After a short break, the podcast is set to return with its regular weekly format, introducing new contributors and professional guests.
This approach will allow the show to explore a broader range of mental health themes, while still maintaining its signature conversational structure.
What Listeners Can Expect:
Weekly new episodes
New guest therapists and mental health experts
More diverse perspectives on therapy culture
Continued focus on internet-driven mental health narratives
Full video versions of episodes on YouTube
TherapyJeff Confirmed as One of the Major Guests
One of the biggest season two announcements is the inclusion of TherapyJeff, a licensed therapist and popular mental health content creator with over four million followers online.
His appearance is expected to attract a wider audience, especially among younger listeners who already engage with therapy content through platforms like TikTok and Instagram.
Why TherapyJeff’s Guest Appearance Matters
His participation could significantly increase the podcast’s visibility by:
Bringing millions of potential new listeners
Creating viral episode moments on social media
Strengthening the show’s credibility and reach
Connecting mainstream therapy with digital culture
Season Two Topics: ADHD, Dating Advice, EMDR Therapy and Trauma Recovery
Season two will cover a mix of trending and clinically relevant mental health themes, many of which are currently dominating online discussions.
The podcast is expected to explore:
Modern Dating Advice and Relationship Psychology
Dating advice has exploded online, but much of it is built on surface-level assumptions and emotionally manipulative strategies.
Season two will examine:
Dating expectations in the social media era
Emotional availability
Attachment patterns
“Red flag culture” and its impact
Healthy vs unhealthy relationship advice
ADHD and Neurodivergence in Adults
Adult ADHD awareness has surged in recent years, as many people recognize symptoms later in life.
The show will explore:
ADHD burnout
Executive dysfunction
Masking behaviors
Late diagnosis struggles
Misconceptions about neurodivergence
EMDR Therapy Explained
EMDR therapy has become one of the most talked-about trauma treatment approaches in recent years.
Season two will likely cover:
What EMDR therapy actually is
Who benefits most from EMDR
Why it’s used for trauma recovery
Common myths around EMDR treatment
Trauma Recovery and Healing
Trauma recovery remains one of the most searched therapy-related topics worldwide.
The podcast is expected to unpack:
How trauma impacts the nervous system
Why healing is not linear
The difference between trauma and stress
Misleading “healing culture” advice online
Body Dysmorphia and Self-Image
With social media filters, unrealistic beauty standards and constant comparison, body dysmorphia and self-image issues have become more common discussion points.
Season two will explore:
Body image and mental health
The role of social media in self-perception
Body dysmorphia warning signs
Therapy-based strategies for recovery
Why These Themes Are Likely to Resonate With Listeners in 2026
The topics planned for season two align closely with what people are searching for and discussing online.
Mental health content is increasingly consumed not just as self-help, but as a way to understand personal relationships, emotional struggles, and identity.
Season two’s topic list suggests the show is positioning itself at the intersection of:
therapy education
pop culture mental health conversations
social media relationship trends
evidence-based psychological insight
New Companion Substack to Offer Exclusive Behind-the-Scenes Content
Alongside the weekly podcast episodes, the team behind What Your Therapist Thinks is also launching an official Substack newsletter.
The new platform will provide listeners with more direct access to the hosts and extended content beyond the audio show.
What the Substack Will Feature:
Post-episode reactions from Kristie and Felicia
Monthly curated recommendations
Extra reflections on mental health topics
A dedicated community space for listeners
The move reflects a growing trend among creators and podcast brands who are building loyal communities outside of algorithm-based social media platforms.
Why Substack Is a Smart Move for Mental Health Creators
Substack has quickly become one of the most popular platforms for independent media and creator-driven communities.
For mental health podcasts, it offers unique benefits, including:
More personal and direct communication with followers
Long-form writing that allows deeper explanation
Community building through comments and discussions
Stronger audience loyalty through email delivery
This expansion could help the podcast grow beyond audio platforms and establish itself as a larger mental health media brand.
Produced by PodVision and Available on All Major Platforms
The podcast is produced by PodVision and will continue to be available across major streaming platforms.
Listeners will be able to access season two through:
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Other major podcast streaming apps
YouTube (full video episodes)
With video podcasting continuing to dominate content trends, the show’s YouTube availability may further strengthen its reach.
Full Video Episodes on YouTube: Boosting Visibility and Engagement
The continued release of full video episodes is likely to support growth, especially as YouTube becomes one of the largest discovery platforms for podcasts.
Benefits of the Video Format:
Higher engagement and watch time
Stronger emotional connection with audiences
Increased chances of appearing in YouTube recommendations
Better SEO performance through searchable titles and keywords
More opportunities for viral short clips
For mental health discussions, video also adds authenticity, allowing viewers to connect with the hosts on a more personal level.
Trailer Now Available Ahead of 25 February Launch
The official trailer for season two has already been released, giving listeners a preview of what’s coming next.
Season two officially launches on 25 February 2026, and new episodes will follow weekly.
Why What Your Therapist Thinks Is One of 2026’s Most Anticipated Podcast Returns
The podcast’s comeback comes at a time when mental health discussions are louder than ever — but also more complicated.
While therapy awareness has grown, misinformation has also increased. Viral therapy language is often repeated without understanding, and many listeners are searching for credible sources that can explain what mental health terms truly mean.
This is where What Your Therapist Thinks continues to stand out.
The show’s success suggests that audiences want:
licensed therapist insight
relatable discussions
clear explanations without judgment
humor and emotional validation
deeper understanding of mental health culture
Key Takeaways: What to Know About Season Two
Quick Summary for Readers
What Your Therapist Thinks is returning for season two
The podcast is hosted by Kristie Plantinga and Felicia Keller Boyle
Season one reached #1 on Apple Podcasts in multiple categories
Season two begins on 25 February 2026
TherapyJeff will appear as a guest
Topics include dating advice, ADHD, neurodivergence, EMDR, trauma recovery and body dysmorphia
A companion Substack is launching alongside the season
FAQs
When does What Your Therapist Thinks season two start?
Season two will officially launch on 25 February 2026.
Where can I listen to the podcast?
The podcast is available on all major platforms including Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and full video episodes on YouTube.
Who are the hosts?
The podcast is hosted by Kristie Plantinga and Felicia Keller Boyle.
Will TherapyJeff appear in season two?
Yes, TherapyJeff has been confirmed as one of the season two guests.
What is the new Substack for?
The Substack will provide exclusive content including post-episode reflections, monthly recommendations and a space for listeners to connect with the hosts.
Conclusion
With its strong first-season performance, high-interest mental health topics and the addition of new guest voices like TherapyJeff, What Your Therapist Thinks is shaping up to be one of the standout mental health podcast series returning in 2026.
The launch of a companion Substack also signals the podcast’s evolution into a broader community-based mental health platform, offering audiences not only weekly episodes but deeper engagement and ongoing expert insight.
As therapy culture continues to trend online, the podcast’s mission to provide clarity, context and professional guidance is likely to resonate even more strongly in its second season.
